another logo

Any opinions on this logo.
This is about the fourth attempt.

Cheers

Pat

Attached Images

pet-plan-compare-logo.jpg (11.2 KB, 65 views)

What is that? A cat or a dog? What's with them being so thin?

In order to see this thing clearly, we need to see the whole site where this logo reside.
I think your attempt is good enough, I like the curly effect there..
Can we see your first, second and third attempt?

first of all the pet plan compare text and the cat and dog is the logo part the rest is part of the header so post a larger image of just the logo part as the header part is fine. In terms of the logo its pretty awful I have to say but thats not to say you can take it somewhere the conceptual idea is nice have ago at using diffrent fonts and tracing a cat and a dog with the peng tool I might do one for you to give you some inspiration if you stuck. If you've got it use illustrator for logos as company logos generally want to be vector photoshop is ok aswell I use a combination of the two programs.

Thanks for the replys. To be honest I didnt like it much, so I have made attempt no5.

Any comments.

Attached Images

pet-compare-logo1.jpg (9.1 KB, 28 views)

massive improvment

Thanks.

May stick with it.

Cheers

Pat

making the eggs abit more dull might fit in abit better with the little curved border things or making the curved border a little more green and brighter to blend better with the eggs

This is definitely a step in the right direction! No offense, but your first attempts were terrible. Reminded me of some 1940's TV Program!

This is 200% improvement.

A lot of people hate the "web 2.0" trend - but it's the way things are going.

Maybe polish this logo up a bit, etc - not the best but still very good.

Thanks,
Ed

Much better. AGain, I would ask to see it in the actual website to be able to give better feedback.

__________________

Thanks Edd, Jack, Sam.

I will try and sharpen it up a bit and repost when I finish.

Cheers

Pat

Ok

Done a bit of playing around and added a bit of the site.
I know this is bordering on a website critique but I just want your opinions on the logo and header.

Cheers

Pat

Attached Images

Pet Compare.com_1200874756953.jpg (29.3 KB, 40 views)

I like it. Simple but nice. Sometimes less is more, and I think it's true in this case.

Nice job.

Thanks for all the replys

I will probably go with it

Pat

Hi, What about having a line of footprints....as aposed to the green things? Starting small and then getting bigger as it gets to the txt.

Just a thought.

Better than the other one, I like it...

what's the 3 green blobs on the top left ? took me more than 20 seconds to figure out what they were so I thought I'd post and ask.

this site needs branding/a brand. There's too many random footprints/animals scattered about. I know it's a pet website but come on...

simplify it.

simple=best