Which Logo? Critique Welcome :)

Jack Franklin · #1 Oct 1st, 2007, 21:14

Mods-please close my other thread.

Which logo looks best for a future site csstrickery.co.uk? (A site full of CSS tips and tricks)

Logo 1:
http://www.jackfranklin.co.uk/web_images/logo1.gif

Logo 2:
http://www.jackfranklin.co.uk/web_images/logo2.gif

Logo 3:
http://www.jackfranklin.co.uk/web_images/logo3.gif

Logo 4:
http://www.jackfranklin.co.uk/web_images/logo4.gif

Comments Welcome

(is it possible to do a poll?)

Jack

alexgeek · #2 Oct 1st, 2007, 21:18

i don't know how they would fit in with the layout
very odd sizes

Jack Franklin · #3 Oct 1st, 2007, 21:22

I do though. Don't worry about layout, just which one do you think is best?

alexgeek · #4 Oct 1st, 2007, 21:25

first i guess.
it really depends what the layout is like

Jack Franklin · #5 Oct 1st, 2007, 21:28

I suspect it will be wordpress. Obviously I might have to change the logos depending on what happens.

sannbe · #6 Oct 1st, 2007, 21:29

1 is boring....2,3, 4 I absolutely love, but if I had to choose, I have to say 3.

Lchad · #7 Oct 2nd, 2007, 00:03

#1 looks a bit on the amateurish side.
#2 is too hard to read.
#3 very nice
#4 also very nice!

Monie · #8 Oct 2nd, 2007, 05:22

I like the #2, if you could put in some outline color to the text, it will be much more readable. maybe black color?

adding some drop shadow would be interesting?

Jack Franklin · #9 Oct 2nd, 2007, 06:16

Thanks for the suggestions. I'm stuck between 3 and 4. I love 2, but it';s slightly hard to read. But I tried to make a new No2 which could be read, I failed, but it still looks nice!

http://www.jackfranklin.co.uk/web_images/logo2-1.gif

I might take the colours of 3 and add them to 4. Hmm

Thanks for the suggestions!

jack

alexgeek · #10 Oct 2nd, 2007, 06:52

I like the new one,
more clear

Monie · #11 Oct 2nd, 2007, 07:02

Thats what I am talking about.
Still the word TRICKERY seems still very hard to read..

alexgeek · #12 Oct 2nd, 2007, 07:05

Add some texture to the word "CSS" I think.

Monie · #13 Oct 2nd, 2007, 07:09

Or perhaps bevel and emboss...
That will make the text a 3d features...
and more readable.

jtyoungs · #14 Oct 2nd, 2007, 08:25

bevel and emboss = bad
you can create same effect using darker and lighter blocks of colour

i like number 3,
would look better with a contrasting colour

Monie · #15 Oct 2nd, 2007, 08:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by jtyoungs

bevel and emboss = bad
you can create same effect using darker and lighter blocks of colour

i like number 3,
would look better with a contrasting colour

Why and what do you mean by that?
What's wrong with bevel and emboss?

Well, that's just a suggestion to alexgeek. Maybe he has a better idea.
Overall, you have to do something with the text otherwise it will be hard to read.

jtyoungs · #16 Oct 2nd, 2007, 08:54

images that looked raised usually look really odd on screen unless there done in a certain way.

welshstew · #17 Oct 2nd, 2007, 11:20

I like number 3, but think it just needs re-arranging.

attached is a possible idea, the 'outside of the box' tag line is meant to be breaking out of the box (sorry only had 5 mins)

anyways, somthing along those lines to give it some 'action' might be the way to go.

or you may wish to switch the tag link to break out of the bottom of the box....

		Webforumz.com > Main Forums > Design Your Website > Graphics and 3D
Which Logo? Critique Welcome :)